On July 13mm Republican presidential candidate former President Donald Trump is rushed off stage during a rally on July 13, 2024 in Butler, Pennsylvania. Leading US socialist party makes the case for working class unity amid increased political instability and empty attempts at fostering unity by the ruling class – Picture: Anna Moneymaker / Getty Images / via AFP
By Peoples Dispatch
On Saturday, July 13, former President Donald Trump was grazed by a bullet in an attempted assassination carried out by 20-year-old Thomas Matthew Crooks. As of this writing, Crooks’ motivation remains unknown.
The shocking attempt quickly captivated the nation and made international headlines, especially with regards to the iconic imagery that emerged of Trump, bleeding from the ear, pumping his fist into the air. The act of political violence served the purpose of effectively supercharge Trump’s campaign.
In a recent statement, leading US socialist party the Party for Socialism and Liberation (PSL) writes about how the Democratic Party has retreated from its rhetorical attacks against Trump in the name of “cooling” and “unity”, while Trump’s Republican Party has only escalated its accusations against the Democrats.
“The main argument the Democratic Party had in the campaign up to now was that Trump was an aspiring dictator and pathological liar who represented an existential threat to democracy.
“They instantly dropped all these talking points in the name of ‘coming together’ and ‘turning down the rhetoric',” the statement reads. “The right wing, on the other hand, immediately went on the attack. JD Vance, a vice-presidential contender, directly blamed Biden’s rhetoric for the shooting.”
Democratic Party attempts for unity are shallow, argues the PSL, and people in the US should instead turn to working class unity.
“Socialists desire working-class unity, but no unity with the tiny billionaire class that has doubled their profits in the last four years by exploiting people of all backgrounds. The problem is not that people are politically polarised, but that we are polarised on totally the wrong basis.”
In an instant, the political situation in the United States was transformed when a gunman shot Donald Trump while he was on stage at a rally in Butler County, Pennsylvania on July 13.
The situation is still evolving, but the initial political impact is highly favourable for Trump. Instructing his Secret Service detail to pause as they evacuated him from the stage, Trump pumped his fist and yelled to the crowd, “Fight!” — instantly creating iconic images that make Trump look heroic and strong.
The contrast between his (self-created and false) image as an unstoppable fighter and Biden’s feebleness has never been greater.
Immediately following the shooting, the Biden campaign suspended its advertisements. Practically every major Democratic Party elected official rushed to express their sympathy for Trump and wish him well. A range of corporate leaders, perhaps seeing Trump’s victory as now inevitable, issued statements embracing him.
The main argument the Democratic Party had in the campaign up to now was that Trump was an aspiring dictator and pathological liar who represented an existential threat to democracy.
They instantly dropped all these talking points in the name of “coming together” and “turning down the rhetoric.” The furthest Biden now goes is to say Trump has a “competing vision” for the country.
The right wing, on the other hand, immediately went on the attack. JD Vance, a vice-presidential contender, directly blamed Biden’s rhetoric for the shooting. Donald Trump, Jr immediately said after the shooting that his father “will never stop fighting to save America, no matter what the radical left throws at him”.
There is zero indication the “radical left” had anything to do with this, as the shooter himself was a registered Republican, but such comments have saturated the far-right political ecosystem.
They are meant to cow Trump’s liberal critics into silence, lest they be seen as supporting violence. It also lays the groundwork and creates a pretext for a new wave of repression, either under a second Trump presidency or even now under Biden.
Already the White House has signalled Biden is planning to go on a new political offensive this week against the campus encampments in solidarity with Palestine as an example of “violent extremism”.
This is absurd. The encampments were launched to stop the genocidal violence against the Palestinian people; the student protesters attacked no one and were, in fact, targets of violence themselves.
Trump is headed to Milwaukee for the Republican National Convention. His speech at the RNC will set the tone for the next phase of the campaign. Trump is reportedly rewriting his speech, which had originally been an all-out attack on Biden, to focus more on themes of national unity.
With leading capitalists extending him an olive branch, Trump could calculate that his best move would be to move in a “moderate” direction and demonstrate to fellow members of the ultra-rich elite that he can be a unifying, “presidential” figure and present strength for the Empire.
Trump has no fixed ideology and solely cares about his image and legacy.
In another sign that an elite consensus was emerging around Trump as the next president, the judge in the classified documents criminal case against Trump suddenly dismissed all charges two days after the assassination attempt.
Soon, a DC judge will have to decide if other charges relating to the plot to overturn the 2020 election can go forward in light of the Supreme Court ruling on presidential immunity.
“There is no place in America for this kind of violence,” Joe Biden says. “No exception.” It is important not to lose sight of the extreme hypocrisy of the powerful figures now issuing blanket condemnations of violence.
The same people who are so appalled that someone would shoot at a politician did not bat an eye at the news the same Saturday morning that Israeli fighter jets had just killed 90 Palestinian civilians in a failed assassination attempt of a resistance leader in Gaza.
They normalise and defend all the violence carried out by the state — whether in oppressed neighbourhoods inside the United States, at the US-Mexico border, or overseas. But then they turn around and say, “violence has never been the answer”.
All the politicians who have suddenly become pacifists for a weekend don’t really mean it. This is about their own safety and no one else’s.
More than anything, they are concerned about a new wave of political violence that could destabilize their rule. Contrary to Biden’s assertions that such political violence is “unheard of”, working-class leaders and social movement leaders have been targeted by violence throughout US history.
There have also been periods of US history where violence and assassination have been the methods used to resolve disputes within the ruling class. The US Civil War came about after years of escalating political violence. A century later, the assassinations of John F Kennedy and Robert F Kennedy in 1963 and 1968 profoundly reshaped the presidential campaigns that were under way in each of those instances.
Then came the shooting that left George Wallace paralysed in the 1972 election, an election which also saw President Nixon order the break-in to the offices of the DNC.
The impeachment of Nixon, and the subsequent appointment of an unelected president and vice-president, Gerald Ford and Nelson Rockefeller, capped off this period of extreme instability in the ruling class — and to end it, Nixon was pardoned in the name of “national unity”.
In periods of major upheaval domestically and internationally, the tendency to resolve struggles within the ruling class using violence grows stronger, as does the tendency to use violence against the people.
Lest we forget: from 2017 to 2020, Democratic Party leaders attempted to undo the 2016 election with the phony Russiagate conspiracy, asserting that Trump was elected because of Russian interference in the election.
From Day One of the Trump presidency, the Democratic Party leadership and their supporters were looking to impeach him for being a “puppet” of Putin. Then, in turn, Trump tried to undo the 2020 election by mobilising fascist forces to seize the Capitol at the moment the vote was to be ratified.
And in between these two events, there was a mass uprising against police killing of unarmed civilians, during which the National Guard was called out, Democratic mayors complied with Trump to impose curfews and conduct mass arrests, and Trump itched to invoke the Insurrection Act and call out the military to occupy cities in the United States. Talk about instability.
Headed into the 2024 election, there remains all the same explosive potential around the election and the transfer of power. The underlying social crises — of job destruction, climate destruction, military confrontation, state violence, the cost-of-living crisis, etc. — cannot be solved by either faction of the capitalist class.
Neither party can control the two egomaniacs who lead them. The trust in Congress, the White House, and the Supreme Court are at record lows. There are already hundreds of millions of guns in circulation among the population.
The country appears to be on a collision course. No wonder they’re saying, “Cool it”.
All this is more important than who, if anyone, the shooter was connected to politically. Theories already abound, and there will now be extensive investigations by multiple different arms of the government with contradictory political interests.
There is intense speculation about how the gunman was able to position himself so close to the stage and why police did not stop him. Some of that may become clearer in the coming weeks, but it also may remain shrouded in mystery. Rather than focus on that, class-conscious workers should pay more attention to how the ruling class will politically utilise this assassination attempt in the here and now.
The Democrats now want to invoke “unity” and American patriotism to silence criticism of the institutions whose legitimacy has been rapidly in decline. The Republicans also talk of unity and wrap themselves in the flag, but they want to use this event to blast through any opposition to their radical pro-corporate agenda.
The hypocrisy of elite politicians aside, they are playing on a sincere feeling among many working-class people that the United States has become deeply divided in a way that has dangerous consequences. People do desire peace over instability, unity over division. The question, then, is what is the answer to “polarisation”?
Socialists desire working-class unity, but no unity with the tiny billionaire class that has doubled their profits in the last four years by exploiting people of all backgrounds. The problem is not that people are politically polarised, but that we are polarised on totally the wrong basis.
Working-class people who vote for Biden or for Trump, or neither, have more in common than they may think. They share the same problems paying for rent, mortgage, a tank of gas, and a dozen eggs while dealing with stagnant wages, disrespectful bosses, decrepit schools, exorbitant childcare, and parasitic insurance companies.
They have almost no democratic say in any of it. They generally want to stay out of wars abroad and would much prefer to see their tax dollars used to build stronger communities.
But both parties, representing two factions of the same ruling class, intentionally keep the working class divided into different political blocks, into the fiction of “blue vs red” so each can be more easily mobilised in favour of their respective rulers, rather than against their common enemy.
Backed by powerful media institutions churning out content, both factions each invent existential threats in the other and drum up points of division to keep workers estranged and voting out of fear. The Republican leaders are, of course, less subtle in their cultural appeals to racism, sexism, and xenophobia.
The Democratic leaders, by contrast, use “politically correct” language to signal sympathy for targeted communities, while doing nothing for them and instead protecting the same system of exploitation and Empire.
For all the harsh rhetoric the two parties use against each other, the truth is that they are just shades apart! On most of the issues that are important to the capitalist class, they are on the same team.
They work for the same lobbyists and banks, enact the same mass surveillance policies against all of us, and work together to fund and arm Israel, Ukraine, and military contractors.
They both work to keep third parties off the ballot and out of the debates. Both scapegoat immigrants for declining services. Neither fights for working people. Our problems won’t be solved when these two parties are more “united”. They are functionally already the same.
As long as this deception continues, and as long as workers have to fight among themselves for the scraps left over by the billionaire class, there will inevitably be countless points of division and conflict.
The basis of broad working-class unity is a programme that advocates for taking away the power of Wall Street and the Military-Industrial Complex, instead using the country’s wealth to build up housing, healthcare, education, and good-paying jobs, while rejecting all forms of hatred and bigotry.
Since its founding, a small group of rich capitalists have maintained a hold on the political power in this country. For over 150 years, they have maintained this grip on power through two ruling-class parties.
The vast majority, those whose labour creates all the real wealth in society, do not hold any political power and are only allowed to participate either as supporters of one of the two parties that don’t represent their needs and interests or as spectators to a system dominated by Big Money.
This is a Plutocracy, not a Democracy. Biden tells the public that Trump is the problem. Trump says that Biden is the problem. The real problem is that the biggest banks, corporations, and capitalist-owned media have dictatorial power over society, the government, and its policies.
We can create a real democracy in the United States by ending the stranglehold on political and economic power by Wall Street banks and corporations, and their political servants in government. – Liberation News
This article was published on Peoples Dispatch